Compare and Contrast: Something Yiddish This Way Comes

on September 28, 2010 by Steve Simels

Nice Jewish Boy Mel Brooks (born Melvin Kaminsky, Brooklyn NY) as the Chief of the Sioux nation in Blazing Saddles (1974)....

MelBrooks-Indian-BlazingSaddles.jpg

...is no sillier than Nice Jewish Boy Jeff Chandler (born Ira Grossel, Brooklyn NY) as Cochise (left) in The Battle At Apache Pass (1952)

jeff_chandler.jpg

I should mention that I had no idea that Chandler -- a slab of beef on feet who I have found inexplicable as a movie star/sex symbol for almost as long as I've been sentient -- was Jewish until I did some web-surfing yesterday. And the reason that I bring him up in the first place is because he appears -- reprising his role as Cochise, albeit briefly and on the character's death bed -- in the 1954 Taza, Son of Cochise (starring the young Rock Hudson, a goyim who also had no business playing a Native American).

Taza, as it turns out, being one of the four lesser known works included in the just released DVD box set Douglas Sirk: Filmmaker Collection (from TCM/Universal).

I'll have more to say about that set in a couple of days, although I should stipulate up front I'm not really a Sirkian. Nonetheless, I was intrigued to learn that Taza (Sirks' only Western) had been shot (although not released theatrically) in 3D; if you have a pair of the red-and-blue glasses lying around from some DVD or other, here's a tantalizing snippet.

Like I said, I'm not a Sirkian, but there's no getting around the fact that he was an incredible visual stylist, and I'm a little disappointed the transfer in the new set is flat; I would have loved to see how he handled the third dimension. In any case, the collection also includes The Tarnished Angels, another Rock Hudson vehicle that's supposed to be a sort-of followup to Written on the Wind, the one Sirk film I am unreservedly enthusiastic about, so I'll keep you posted.

read all Simels »


8 Comments

  • sid sherman on 28 September 2010

    A 3D clip? Good thing I kept my copy of that otherwise godawful Brendan Frasier Journey to the Center of the Earth DVD.

  • Gummo on 28 September 2010

    Back when Blazing Saddles was still in theaters, I heard that Brooks's Yiddish Indian chief was actually subtitled in the south -- I've never found out if that was true.

  • fmcgrath on 28 September 2010

    "...Hudson, a goyim who..." Surely you meant the singular "goy," no?

  • steve simels on 28 September 2010

    See -- this is why everybody needs an editor.
    :-)

  • Gwen De Marco on 28 September 2010

    Mel Brooks is Jewish?????
    ;-)

  • kurt b. on 28 September 2010

    Re-watched "Tarnished Angels" this weekend on a nice quality Spanish DVD I've had for a couple years. Beautiful black & white cinemascope. My favorite Sirk.

  • pajamas51 on 29 September 2010

    Jeff Chandler is Jewish? And a cross dresser? Say it isn't so, Cochise!

  • trademarkdave on 30 September 2010

    You want Jewish Indians, check out all those "comedy" westerns on TV in the 60s. "F Troop" is particularly fertile...

What do you think?

Trailers